Back to History

James Calder included many traditional folktales in his History of Caithness, recognising that they were remnants of local history distorted by generations of oral transmission. It is seldom possible to test the historical accuracy of folk-tales, however at the south-east corner of Loch Watten is a spot where this might just be possible.

The first edition of the OS map of this area shows a dotted circle bearing the title Uaigh Mhurcha Riabhaich and the corresponding entry in the OS Name Book reads, “This is rather a peculiar feature situated about l2Oyards south from the S.E. end of Loch Watten, in a field close to the public road; its formation is circular being about 60 links (approx 39 1/2 ft) in diameter~ The relevant section of the map is reproduced below, on page 22. The clay from which it is composed, differs totally from that of the surrounding fields, and would lead to the idea that it was formerly trenched round. It may be the remains of an ancient Danish camp, but nothing definite is known in the locality respecting it, except that a wizard named Mhurcha Riabhaich was shot and buried here about 150 years ago, hence the name (Ref 1).

This then was the local tradition, about 1872, as related to the map makers by, Sergeant Mackay; Robert Mieklejohn, grocer; and John Doull, Post Office. Suspecting that the feature might be rather older the surveyors suggest that it could be a ‘Danish camp’, their catch-all title for sites which could not be easily classified. However, Uaigh Mhurcha Riabhaich is much smaller than any known ring fort in the county (Ref 2).

Although the field has been ploughed many times there is still a circular depression at ND 2455 5480. It is now about 34 ft in diameter and approximately 6inches deep, with a decided hump in the centre. In this respect it is unlike a hut circle. 
The OS surveyors were right to assume that the date given by local tradition was inaccurate. An earlier version of the Murdo Rivach tale, collected by Captain Gunn of Braehour (Ref 3) ,links Rivach with other historical characters. In essence the story relates how Paul Macintyre, from Creich in Sutherland, had the right to take custom cows from Caithness provided he did so in person. One year, when he was busy, he sent his son Gillespie with a supporting party led by Murdo Rivach Mackenzie. While driving the cows south, they were ambushed between the river and the east end of Loch Watten, by a superior force of Caithness men. Both Murdo and Gillespie lost their lives. An attempt to take Gillespie’s remains home to Creich fluiled when the body was washed away as the company forded the river at Helmsdale. Murdo Rivach was buried where he fell and the mark of his grave is still to be seen, only his head was taken south. While the party was crossing the Ord a squabble broke out among those carrying the gruesome relic and it was lost over the cliff. His two handed sword was preserved for sometime by the Budges of Toftingall who eventually returned it to Kenneth Mackenzie of Seaforth in 1688.

Paul Macintyre or Mactyre or Meutier appears in several historical records between 1350 and 1372. He held Creichmore near Bonar Bridge, and is said to have built the medieval tower within the vitrified fort on top of Dun Creich.

In 1365 he was granted additional lands in Strath Oykell by his father-in-law Hugh Ross, brother of the Earl of Ross (Ref 4).

This same Hugh Ross of Philorth had in 1361 bought, from James Prat of Kerdale, in Buchan a yearly rent of 6 marks sterling due from the lands of Fraswiln (Freswick), Okyngil (Aukengill) and Harpsdol (Harpsdale) for the sum of 35 marks sterling to be paid by Hugh on recovering the same by law (Ref 5).

The true historical background to the traditional tale of Murdo Rivach is of an absentee landlord having difficulty obtaining rents from his lands in Caithness so he sells the right to Hugh Ross. Hugh entrusts their collection to his son-in-law Paul MacTyre, who in turn sends his son Gillespie and Murdo Rivach into Caithness. They gather cattle in payment from Freswick and Aukengill and are waylaid at Watten as they head south to collect the Harpsdale rents. The skirmish at Watten can probably be dated between 1361 when Hugh Ross bought the rents in Caithness and 1365 when Paul Mactyre was granted additional lands in Strath Oykell, possibly as compensation for the loss of his son.

It is hardly surprising that a Wizard has become attached to the tale. What is remarkable is that Mhurcha Riabhaich ‘s name, in contemporary Gaelic, has been linked to this spot for over six hundred years. It opens up the possibility that other aspects of the folktale are also true.

Taking a head as a triumphal trophy is well recorded for earlier periods but here a new twist is added to this bizarre ritual with the losing side taking their leaders head home after the battle. Perhaps this custom was more widespread than we believe, for just a short distance upstream from Murdo’s grave, lies the Clow chapel which revealed a number of ‘skull only’ burials when the graveyard was excavated in the 1970s. Were these the remains of Caithness men who had died on some distant battlefield?

The history of Caithness in the 14th century is patchy, Norse influence had all but disappeared and nascent Scottish power was still diffuse, being filtered through the distant Earldom of Ross. An archaeological investigation of Murdo Rivach’s grave, with its background of oral and written history would open an interesting window on this shadowy period. Perhaps Highland Archaeology Week could provide the equipment and expertise to carry out a preliminary resistivity survey to confirm the existence of a grave beneath the slight surface indications.

          2. Concentric Earthworks, G Leet, Caithness Field Club Bulletin, April 1997, Vol 6, No 2, p28.